A Sovereign Trap: Critical Infrastructure and National Security

A Sovereign Trap: Critical Infrastructure and National Security

Under the guise of defending the sovereignty of the Malvinas Islands, a bill is advancing in Congress under the title “Ley de Defensa de la Soberanía Nacional” (National Sovereignty Defense Law), the scope of which far exceeds this issue. Of the eight chapters that comprise it, only the first addresses the sovereignty claim. The remaining chapters introduce reforms to the laws on national defense, political party and intelligence services financing, in addition to foreseeing the creation of a National Security Council chaired by the Head of State and composed of Executive Branch officials.

Within this framework, the bill seeks to shield so-called “critical infrastructure” across the entire national territory. Critical infrastructures are considered to be the “physical structures, networks, systems, or parts thereof, public or private, indispensable for the proper functioning of society’s essential services, health, security, defense, the economy, and the effective functioning of the State”1.

The breadth of this definition turns critical infrastructures into a central axis of the analysis of the initiative: it is necessary to examine which facilities and activities would be covered, who would have the authority to identify them, and what consequences that classification would have for the exercise of rights and democratic oversight.

If this bill is passed, key infrastructure works for the expansion of Vaca Muerta—such as oil pipelines, gas pipelines, port terminals, and LNG liquefaction vessels—as well as mega-mining projects in the Andes or data centers for Artificial Intelligence in Patagonia will enjoy enormous protection following the creation of a National Security Council. In the name of national defense, the bill states that the Armed Forces must be prepared to be deployed, where appropriate, for the protection of the critical infrastructures identified by the National Security Council2.

That Council will be headed by the President and will be tasked with drafting “the National Strategy and the National Plan for Critical Infrastructure Security, identifying Critical Infrastructures of national interest, and coordinating their protection, including that of binational or plurinational infrastructures”3. In this way, binational mining projects between Argentina and Chile, such as the Vicuña project, or the energy integration of Vaca Muerta with Chilean infrastructure for gas exports could be covered by the national security plan and strategy. Both countries are undergoing a phase of deregulation and rollbacks in environmental protection and seek to promote investments regardless of environmental costs. It should be remembered that in April of this year, a law was enacted that weakens the protection of glaciers as strategic water reserves, thereby favoring binational mining projects.

According to the bill, the National Strategy for Critical Infrastructure Security will contemplate the “impact that its impairment or destruction may produce”4. What is meant by impairment and destruction? Nobody knows. And that is dangerous. The lack of clarity of the bill in question leaves the door open to the discretion/arbitrariness of the government in power and suggests that actions such as demonstrations, legal actions, court rulings, and communication campaigns could be covered by this definition. Precisely, the National Security Council will be able to define the measures necessary to guarantee the protection of critical infrastructure5. Nor is there clarity or precision regarding the measures it can take, which opens yet another line of uncertainty.

The sovereignty defense bill seeks to deepen the path initiated by Decree 1107/2024, which granted the President the authority to define which facilities constitute “Strategic Value Objectives” to be guarded by military and police forces, and continued by the Unified Productive Security Command through Resolution 893/24 of the Ministry of Security. That Command was created to control “order in the country’s productive enclaves.” The creation of the Command before, and of the Security Council whose creation is now sought, ignores the fact that most of the time those who peacefully protest against large infrastructure projects with high environmental impacts in the territories are local, Indigenous, peasant, or urban communities, considered environmental defenders, who are specially protected by international standards such as the Regional Agreement on Access to Information, Public Participation and Justice in Environmental Matters in Latin America and the Caribbean (Escazú Agreement, approved in the country by Law 27,566). Furthermore, the proposal frames international financing as a potential threat to national security. This classification enables serious administrative and criminal consequences that could directly impact the work of environmental and community organizations that receive funds from abroad.

Article 9 of the Escazú Agreement establishes the obligation to protect environmental defenders and guarantee them a safe and enabling environment in which to act without restrictions or threats. In Argentina, however, the current Government is sending signals to the contrary. The protection of strategic infrastructure is privileged over human rights and over guaranteeing a safe environment for environmental protection. In effect, the bill seeks to guarantee the uninterrupted continuity of extractive projects at the expense of constitutional guarantees and individual freedoms.

Returning to the national security doctrine, which blurs the boundaries between internal security and defense, implies reviving a political practice associated in our country with State terrorism and grave human rights violations. Thus, through vague and broad concepts, it seeks to endow the Executive Branch with enormous discretion to single out “internal enemies” upon whom the full punitive rigor of the State will fall.

While privileges, tax exemptions, and regulatory stability are granted to companies for 30 years through the Incentive Regime for Large Investments (RIGI), the national security doctrine seeks to make its way to provide an implacable shield for projects heavily questioned for the environmental, climate, and ecosystemic damages they could generate. This legal framework attempts to go unnoticed under the slogan of “national sovereignty.” Under no circumstances can the National Congress fall into the trap and endorse this initiative. What is at stake is much more important than critical infrastructure. It is about fundamental rights. And there is no better defense of sovereignty than honoring those rights.

Signatories:

  • Fundación Ambiente y Recursos Naturales (FARN)
  • Centro de Estudios Legales y Sociales (CELS)
  • Asociación Argentina de Abogados/as Ambientalistas
  • Observatorio Petrolero Sur
  • Fundación Servicio Paz y Justicia
  • Círculo de Políticas Ambientales
  • Árbol de Pie
  • Centro de Ex Combatientes Islas Malvinas de La Plata (CECIM La Plata)
  • CEPPAS
  • Capibara
  • Multisectorial Golfo San Matías
  • Surfrider Foundation Argentina
  • TRAMAS Derecho en Movimiento
  • CAUCE Cultura Ambiental Causa Ecologista
  • Fundeps
  • Oikos Red Ambiental
  • Asociación Ciudadana por los Derechos Humanos
  • Foro Santafesino por la Salud y el Ambiente
  • Comité de Cuenca Popular del Paraná Santafesino

1. Article 85 of the National Sovereignty Defense Bill.

2. Article 121 of the National Sovereignty Defense Bill.

3. Article 52, subsection G of the National Sovereignty Defense Bill.

4. Article 86, subsection A of the National Sovereignty Defense Bill.

5. Article 92 of the National Sovereignty Defense Bill.

Read More

Sign up to
our newsletter

What are you looking for?

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.